If you’ve been hurt at work in California and you already had a medical issue before the injury, you’re probably asking the same question thousands of other workers search every month: “Can I still get workers’ compensation if I have a pre-existing condition?”
The short answer is YES — in most cases you absolutely can, and often the benefits can be even higher because of the pre-existing condition. But the insurance company will fight tooth and nail to deny or reduce your claim by blaming everything on your “old injury.”
This comprehensive guide explains exactly how California law treats pre-existing conditions in workers’ comp cases, what your rights are, and how an experienced workers’ compensation attorney can turn a denied claim into full benefits.
At Laguna Law Firm, we’ve helped hundreds of injured workers in Orange County and throughout Southern California get the compensation they deserve — even when the insurance carrier insisted “it was pre-existing.” Call us today at (949) 930-1386 for a free consultation or visit lagunalawfirm.com.
What California Law Actually Says About Pre-Existing Conditions
California is one of the most employee-friendly workers’ compensation states in the country. Two key legal principles protect you:
- Labor Code § 4663 & § 4664 – Apportionment Rules
Insurance doctors love to say “only 20% of your disability is from the work injury — 80% is pre-existing.” That’s called apportionment. But California courts have repeatedly ruled that if your work injury aggravates, accelerates, or “lights up” a pre-existing condition, the employer is responsible for all medical treatment and disability that results — not just a percentage. - The “Compensable Consequence” Doctrine
Even if you had arthritis, degenerative disc disease, diabetes, or a prior surgery, if the new work injury makes it worse, the worsening is 100% compensable.
Real-world examples we see every week at Laguna Law Firm:
- Warehouse worker with prior low-back strain now has a herniated disc after lifting a heavy box → fully covered
- Nurse with pre-existing carpal tunnel who develops severe symptoms after repetitive IV insertions → fully covered
- Construction worker with childhood knee injury that becomes totally disabling after a fall from scaffolding → fully covered
The 6 Most Common Pre-Existing Conditions That Still Qualify for Benefits in California
- Degenerative Disc Disease & Arthritis
Insurance companies love to blame “age-related changes.” But if repetitive trauma or a specific incident at work worsens the condition to the point you need surgery or can’t work, you win. - Prior Surgeries (back, knee, shoulder)
A previous surgery does NOT bar you from benefits. In fact, the law provides extra compensation when a new injury affects a body part that was previously impaired (LC 4664(b) subtraction rule often works in the employee’s favor). - Diabetes & Heart Conditions
California recognizes “cumulative trauma” and “occupational disease.” Long-term stress, poor ergonomics, or chemical exposures that worsen diabetes or trigger cardiac events are compensable. - Mental Health Conditions (anxiety, depression, PTSD)
If workplace stress or a physical injury triggers or aggravates psychiatric conditions, you may have a compensable “psyche” claim — especially after violent incidents or severe trauma. - Cancer & Occupational Diseases
Firefighters, police officers, and industrial workers with prior exposures often qualify for presumptions that make pre-existing cancers fully covered. - Old Sports Injuries or Car Accident Injuries
Even if you were 100% healed from a high school football knee tear or a prior car wreck, a new work injury that re-tears the same ligament is compensable.
How Insurance Companies Try to Deny Pre-Existing Condition Claims (And How We Stop Them)
The insurance adjuster and their doctors will use these five dirty tricks:
- Sending you to a “defense-friendly” QME/AME who always apportions 70-90% to pre-existing
- Cherry-picking old medical records (sometimes from 20 years ago) to argue your current pain was already there
- Delaying or denying treatment while claiming it’s for “non-industrial” issues
- Offering a lowball “compromise and release” that factors in massive apportionment
- Utilization Review (UR) denials for surgeries or therapy by anonymous doctors who never examine you
At Laguna Law Firm, we fight back with:
- Depositions of the insurance doctors
- Second opinions from top-rated QMEs who actually follow California law
- Petitions to the Workers’ Compensation Appeals Board (WCAB)
- Aggressive trial preparation that forces fair settlements
Real Case Results from Laguna Law Firm (2023–2025)
- $475,000 settlement – Delivery driver with pre-existing lumbar degenerative disc disease required fusion after repetitive lifting
- $350,000 settlement – Teacher with prior knee replacement needed revision surgery after classroom fall
- $285,000 settlement – Factory worker with childhood shoulder injury developed rotator cuff tear from repetitive overhead work
- 100% permanent disability award – Police officer with pre-existing PTSD aggravated by officer-involved shooting
(All cases are real but names and details changed for privacy)
What Should You Do If Your Claim Is Denied Because of a Pre-Existing Condition?
- Do NOT sign anything the insurance company sends you
- Do NOT give a recorded statement without an attorney
- Get all your old medical records yourself — don’t let the insurance company be the only one who sees them
- Call Laguna Law Firm immediately at (949) 930-1386 — the consultation is free and we advance all costs
Frequently Asked Questions About Pre-Existing Conditions in California Workers’ Comp
Q: If I told my employer about a previous injury when I was hired, does that hurt my claim?
A: No. Disclosure actually helps prove the employer accepted you “as is.”
Q: Can I get a cash settlement instead of weekly checks?
A: Yes — most of our pre-existing condition cases settle for six-figure lump sums.
Q: How long do I have to file a claim if my old injury just got worse?
A: Usually one year from the date you realized (or should have realized) the worsening was work-related — but cumulative trauma claims can have much longer statutes of limitations.
Q: Will my personal health insurance have to pay if workers’ comp denies me?
A: They might — but then they can place a lien on your eventual workers’ comp settlement. We help eliminate or reduce those liens.
Why Orange County & Southern California Workers Trust Laguna Law Firm
- 20+ years fighting the same insurance companies
- Spanish-speaking staff available
- No fee unless we win
- Evening and weekend appointments
- We come to you if you can’t travel
If you’re searching for:
- “workers compensation attorney pre-existing condition California”
- “can I get workers comp if I had previous back surgery”
- “Orange County workers comp lawyer denied claim pre-existing”
- “California workers compensation aggravation of prior injury”
- “best lawyer for denied workers comp claim Laguna Beach”
…you’ve found the right firm.
Take Action Today — Don’t Let the Insurance Company Win
The insurance company hopes you’ll give up when they blame your “pre-existing condition.” They count on injured workers not knowing California law actually protects you in these exact situations.
One phone call can change everything.
Call Laguna Law Firm now at (949) 930-1386
We only get paid if you win — and we’ve been winning pre-existing condition cases for injured California workers for two decades.
You worked hard. You got hurt worse because of the job. You deserve full benefits — not excuses.
Let us fight for you.
Laguna Law Firm
Workers’ Compensation Attorneys Serving All of California
Main Office: Laguna Beach | Satellite Offices: Irvine, Santa Ana, Riverside
Phone: (949) 930-1386
Website: lagunalawfirm.com
Spanish 
English 